Combining credit cards, personal loans and car finance into your mortgage can reduce your monthly repayments. But that doesn't automatically mean you're saving money.
In some cases, debt consolidation can make repayments more manageable and reduce the interest rate on expensive unsecured debts.
In others, it can turn a debt you could have cleared in five years into one that takes thirty years to repay.
The monthly repayment looks better. The total cost can be substantially worse.
That's the distinction I want borrowers to understand before they make a decision.
Debt consolidation can reduce financial pressure, but the real cost depends on the new interest rate, loan term, refinancing fees, security arrangements and how quickly you repay the consolidated balance.
The lowest monthly repayment is not necessarily the cheapest option.
The Question You Should Ask Instead
This is where I would begin the conversation.
Consider a hypothetical homeowner with $35,000 in personal debts.
They have credit card balances and a personal loan. The repayments are becoming uncomfortable, especially alongside their existing mortgage.
They ask whether we can put the $35,000 into their home loan to reduce their monthly commitments.
It's a reasonable question.
But before looking at a refinance, I would want to know how much interest they are currently paying, how long the debts have left to run and what happens if we extend that balance over the mortgage term.
A lower repayment may solve an immediate cash-flow problem.
But if the borrower ends up paying significantly more interest over time, we need to make sure they understand that trade-off.
What Is Debt Consolidation?
Debt consolidation means combining two or more existing debts into a new borrowing arrangement.
For example, you may have:
- Two credit cards with outstanding balances.
- A personal loan.
- A car loan.
Instead of managing several repayments, you may be able to replace those debts with one loan or a separate mortgage split.
There are different ways to do this.
Consolidation Through a Personal Loan
A new personal loan may be used to repay several existing unsecured debts. The new loan has its own interest rate, fees and repayment term. This approach does not necessarily involve your home as security.
Consolidation Into a Mortgage
An eligible homeowner may be able to refinance or increase their mortgage to repay other debts. The attraction is often a lower interest rate than credit cards or personal loans.
However, the consolidated amount may become secured against the property. That changes the risk as well as the repayment.
The $35,000 Debt Example: Lower Repayment, Different Total Cost
Let's compare three hypothetical ways to repay the same $35,000 debt.
Three Repayment Scenarios
| Scenario | Monthly Repayment | Total Interest |
|---|---|---|
| Personal loan at 15%, over 5 years | Approximately $833 | Approximately $15,000 |
| Mortgage split at 6%, over 30 years | Approximately $210 | Approximately $40,500 |
| Mortgage split at 6%, over 5 years | Approximately $677 | Approximately $5,600 |
Illustrative calculations only. Assumes a $35,000 principal, fixed interest rates for the stated terms, monthly principal-and-interest repayments and no fees. Figures are rounded. These are not current lender offers.
Look at the difference between the first and second scenarios. The monthly repayment falls from approximately $833 to $210.
That's a reduction of more than $600 per month. For someone struggling with cash flow, that could be a meaningful difference.
But if they only make the minimum repayments over thirty years, the interest bill could increase from approximately $15,000 to more than $40,000. They would pay far less each month, but considerably more interest overall.
Now Look at the Third Option
The same $35,000 consolidated into a mortgage split at 6%, but repaid over five years, produces a different result. The monthly repayment is approximately $677, and the total interest is around $5,600.
Under these assumptions, that's lower than the original personal loan repayment and substantially lower in total interest.
The difference isn't simply the interest rate. It's the combination of interest rate and repayment period.
When comparing debt consolidation options, ask for both the monthly repayment and the total amount payable over the proposed term.
A lower rate can still result in more interest if the debt is repaid over a much longer period.
Why Extending the Loan Term Can Cost So Much
Interest is calculated on the outstanding loan balance. When you stretch repayments over a longer period, the balance generally reduces more slowly. That means interest can continue accumulating for many more years.
For example, a credit card or personal loan that might otherwise be cleared in five years could remain part of your mortgage for decades. The lower repayment is attractive because less principal is being repaid each month. But that can be exactly why the total interest cost becomes higher.
What If You Make Extra Repayments?
A longer contractual term does not necessarily mean you must take the full term to repay the consolidated debt. Some variable-rate loan products allow additional repayments, subject to their terms.
If you consistently pay more than the minimum, you may reduce the balance sooner. However, I would not build a comparison around extra repayments that you are unlikely to maintain. The repayment plan needs to be realistic for your income and household budget.
The Risk of Turning Unsecured Debt Into Debt Secured by Your Home
This is one of the most important considerations when consolidating personal debt into a mortgage. Credit cards and many personal loans are unsecured.
That generally means they are not supported by a mortgage over your property. When you refinance those balances into your home loan, the new borrowing may be secured against your home. That changes the consequences if repayments cannot be maintained.
If you default on a mortgage secured against your property, the lender may ultimately take enforcement action, including selling the secured property, subject to applicable legal requirements.
Consolidating unsecured debts into a home loan can therefore increase the security risk associated with those debts.
That does not mean mortgage consolidation is always inappropriate. It means the lower interest rate needs to be weighed against the additional risk being taken. A comparison based only on monthly repayments would miss this entirely.
The Debt Consolidation Costs People Forget
A refinance can involve costs beyond the interest rate.
Depending on the existing loans and the proposed lender, these may include:
- Existing mortgage discharge fees.
- New lender application or establishment fees.
- Valuation fees, where applicable.
- Government registration fees.
- Fixed-rate break costs, where applicable.
- Personal loan early payout fees.
- Ongoing package or account fees.
- Lenders mortgage insurance, if required.
There may also be a change to the interest rate on your existing mortgage balance. This is especially important when the amount being consolidated is relatively small compared with the mortgage.
A $35,000 Consolidation Could Affect a Much Larger Loan
Imagine you have an existing $600,000 mortgage and want to consolidate $35,000 of personal debt. If refinancing requires you to move the entire $600,000 mortgage to a different lender, the rate and fees on that larger balance matter.
A slightly worse rate on the main mortgage could offset some or all of the savings achieved on the smaller consolidated debt. This is why I would compare the whole proposed lending arrangement, not just the interest rate on the $35,000. You can explore repayment differences using our refinance calculator .
Should Consolidated Debt Be Kept in a Separate Mortgage Split?
A separate mortgage split can make the consolidated debt easier to identify and track.
For example, rather than adding $35,000 directly to a $600,000 home loan balance, a lender may allow a separate $35,000 split.
That split may have its own repayment arrangement, subject to lender policy. This can make it easier to see whether the consolidated balance is reducing at the intended rate.
Why the Repayment Term Matters
If the intention is to clear the consolidated debt within five years, the repayment arrangement should be assessed against that objective.
A separate split does not, by itself, guarantee faster repayment or lower interest. The actual repayments, rate, fees and loan term still determine the outcome. A split also remains part of the secured mortgage arrangement where it is secured against your home.
If you are comparing loan features, our guide to offset accounts and redraw facilities explains how those features differ.
What Happens If You Keep Using Your Credit Cards?
This is a risk that deserves more attention than it usually gets. Suppose you consolidate $20,000 of credit card debt into your mortgage. The credit card balance is cleared, but the card remains open.
If you then start using the card again and carry a new balance, you may end up with:
- The additional $20,000 in mortgage debt.
- A new credit card balance.
- Interest and repayments on both debts.
In other words, the original debt has not disappeared. It has moved into the mortgage, and new debt has been added. Before consolidating, it is worth considering why the debts accumulated and what will change afterwards.
Some lenders may require particular debts to be paid out and facilities to be reduced or closed as a condition of approval. Closing credit facilities should also be considered in the context of your emergency savings and overall circumstances.
How Do Lenders Assess Debt Consolidation?
Debt consolidation is not simply a matter of having enough equity. The lender generally needs to assess whether the proposed loan is suitable under its credit policy and whether you can meet the repayments.
The assessment may consider:
- Your income and employment circumstances.
- Living expenses and household commitments.
- Existing mortgage and other debts.
- Credit limits and repayment history.
- Recent missed payments or defaults.
- The purpose of the additional borrowing.
- Available property equity and LVR.
- The proposed repayment arrangements.
Some lenders may apply additional requirements where the purpose is debt consolidation. They may also want evidence of the balances being repaid and confirmation that specified accounts have been closed or reduced.
Why Your Bank Statements Matter
Lenders may review transaction history to understand your financial commitments and repayment conduct. Repeated dishonours, missed repayments or persistent reliance on short-term credit may raise questions about the sustainability of the proposed arrangement.
For a more detailed explanation, read our guide to what lenders actually look for in your bank statements .
Will Debt Consolidation Improve Your Borrowing Capacity?
Not automatically. Your actual monthly repayment may fall after consolidation. But lenders do not always assess borrowing capacity using only the repayment you currently make.
They may apply assessment rates, buffers and other serviceability requirements. The additional mortgage balance also becomes part of your overall debt position.
If credit cards remain open, their limits may continue to affect the assessment. The outcome depends on the lender's policy and your overall financial circumstances. You can read more in our guide to how much you can actually borrow .
Debt consolidation may improve your household cash flow without producing the same improvement in a lender's serviceability calculation.
When Might Debt Consolidation Be Worth Considering?
Debt consolidation can be useful in some circumstances.
When the Existing Debts Carry High Interest Rates
Moving eligible debts to a lower-rate product may reduce interest costs, provided the repayment term and fees do not outweigh the benefit.
When Several Repayments Are Difficult to Manage
A simpler repayment arrangement may make budgeting easier. That can be valuable when multiple payment dates and changing balances create financial pressure.
When There Is a Realistic Repayment Plan
The benefits are clearer when the borrower understands how the consolidated balance will be repaid. That might involve a defined loan term or planned additional repayments, subject to product conditions.
When the Whole Loan Comparison Shows a Benefit
The proposed arrangement should be compared with keeping the existing debts. That means including interest, fees, repayment periods and the impact on the main mortgage. The decision should also account for the additional security risk where the debts are moved onto a home loan.
When Could Debt Consolidation Make Things Worse?
Potential Benefits
- Lower monthly repayments.
- Potentially lower interest rates.
- Fewer debts to manage.
- More predictable repayment arrangements.
- Potential interest savings with a shorter term.
Potential Risks
- Higher total interest over a longer term.
- Additional refinancing and payout costs.
- Turning unsecured debt into secured debt.
- Rebuilding credit card balances.
- Reducing available equity in your home.
Debt consolidation may be less suitable where the borrower cannot afford the new repayments or where the proposed arrangement does not address the cause of the existing debt.
It can also be expensive if substantial break costs or other refinancing fees apply. And where the consolidated debt is secured against a home, the consequences of default can be more serious.
What Are the Alternatives to Refinancing?
Refinancing is not the only way to deal with multiple debts.
Speak With Your Existing Lenders
Depending on your circumstances, your current lender may have options worth discussing. These could include reviewing your interest rate, repayment arrangements or available hardship assistance.
Repay Higher-Interest Debts Faster
Some borrowers may be able to reduce interest costs by directing additional repayments towards higher-rate debts. This depends on affordability and the terms of each facility.
Compare Unsecured Consolidation Loans
An unsecured personal loan may provide an alternative to increasing mortgage debt. Its interest rate and repayment may be higher, but it may avoid adding the debt to your home security.
Seek Financial Hardship Assistance
If you are struggling to meet essential expenses or existing repayments, taking on more secured debt may not resolve the problem.
- Contact your lenders' hardship teams to discuss available assistance.
- Free financial counselling is also available in Australia.
You can visit ASIC MoneySmart's financial counselling information or contact the National Debt Helpline .
Do not assume that refinancing or increasing a mortgage is the best solution.
Independent financial counselling can help you understand your options before committing to a new loan.
Seven Questions to Ask Before Consolidating Debt
- 1. How much do I owe today? Obtain accurate payout figures for every existing debt.
- 2. What interest rates am I paying? Compare the rates and remaining terms of the current facilities.
- 3. What will the new loan cost? Include interest, establishment fees, discharge costs and other relevant charges.
- 4. How long will I take to repay it? Compare total interest over the actual proposed term.
- 5. Will the debt become secured against my home? Understand the additional risk before proceeding.
- 6. What happens to my existing credit facilities? Consider whether accounts will be reduced or closed and how future spending will be managed.
- 7. What if my circumstances change? Consider reduced income, unexpected expenses and your ability to maintain the repayments.
How Triple O Finance Can Help You Compare Debt Consolidation Options
When someone asks me whether they should consolidate their debts into a mortgage, I would not begin by looking for the lowest monthly repayment. I would begin by understanding their existing debts, repayment commitments and the reason they are considering consolidation.
Then we can compare the available lending options and their overall costs.
At Triple O Finance, we can help you assess:
- Existing debt balances and payout requirements.
- Potential home loan and refinance options.
- Interest rates, fees and repayment periods.
- Separate loan split arrangements.
- Property equity and lender LVR requirements.
- Serviceability and credit policy considerations.
- The impact of consolidation on your main mortgage.
- How proposed repayments compare with existing commitments.
We can provide credit assistance within the scope of our authorisation. We cannot guarantee approval, future interest rates or that a consolidation arrangement will improve your financial position.
Where financial hardship or broader financial planning issues are involved, independent specialist assistance may be appropriate.
Thinking About Consolidating Your Debts?
Before moving credit cards, personal loans or car finance into your mortgage, understand the total repayment cost, the loan term and the risks.
We can help you compare available lending options and assess the implications for your home loan.
Get a Free Assessment