You've found a property, negotiated the price and started arranging your home loan. Then the bank valuation comes back lower than the price you've agreed to pay.
It's understandably frustrating, particularly when settlement is approaching and you've already committed to the purchase. The first reaction is often to ask whether the bank can simply order another valuation. Sometimes another valuation is possible. But that isn't where I would start.
A low valuation does not automatically mean your loan will be declined, or that the property is worth less than you thought.
What matters immediately is whether the valuation changes the amount the lender is prepared to advance and whether you can still complete the purchase.
When a bank valuation is lower than the purchase price, the lender may calculate its lending limit using the lower figure.
That can increase your loan-to-value ratio, reduce the available loan amount and create a funding shortfall. Your options depend on the lender, the contract, your available funds and the time remaining before settlement.
The Question You Should Ask First
This is the question I would work through before deciding whether another valuation or another lender is necessary. Let's consider a hypothetical situation.
A couple agrees to purchase a home for $800,000. They have planned around an 80% loan and have enough savings for their deposit and purchase costs.
The lender then values the property at $750,000.
The couple asks whether we should immediately apply with another bank. My first step would be to calculate the funding difference, review the lender's valuation process and establish how much flexibility remains before settlement.
Changing lenders may be one option, but it should not be the automatic response.
What Does a Low Bank Valuation Actually Mean?
A bank valuation is an assessment of the property's value used by the lender when deciding how much it is prepared to lend against that security.
The purchase price is the amount the buyer and seller have agreed upon. Those figures are related, but they are not necessarily identical. A valuation may consider recent comparable sales, the property's condition, location, characteristics and prevailing market conditions.
Depending on the lender and property, the assessment may involve an automated valuation, a desktop assessment or a physical inspection.
For a purchase, lenders commonly use the lower of the contract price and the accepted valuation when calculating their lending exposure, although individual policy requirements vary.
This is why a lower valuation can affect your finance even when your income and credit position have not changed.
The $50,000 Valuation Shortfall Example
The important point is that a $50,000 valuation shortfall does not automatically mean you need another $50,000 in cash.
Let's look at the numbers.
Illustrative Purchase
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Contract purchase price | $800,000 |
| Bank valuation | $750,000 |
| Difference in value | $50,000 |
| Planned LVR | 80% |
| 80% of contract price | $640,000 |
| 80% of bank valuation | $600,000 |
| Potential funding shortfall | $40,000 |
If the couple originally planned to borrow $640,000, an 80% limit applied to the lower valuation would reduce the available loan to $600,000.
They would need to fund the $40,000 difference through additional cash or another acceptable arrangement.
Their original $160,000 contribution towards the price would effectively increase to $200,000, excluding purchase costs.
Illustrative example only. Assumes an 80% LVR limit, no additional security, sufficient serviceability and no alternative lender arrangements. Actual lending limits and costs vary.
What If the Buyer Has Less Than a 20% Deposit?
The same valuation difference can have a different effect when a borrower is already seeking high-LVR lending. A lower accepted valuation may push the proposed loan above the lender's maximum permitted LVR.
It can also change lenders' mortgage insurance requirements or affect eligibility for a particular loan product. This is why we need to calculate the outcome using the actual lender policy, rather than assuming the funding shortfall is always 80% of the valuation difference.
Why Do Bank Valuations Come In Low?
1. Recent Comparable Sales
Valuers commonly consider recent sales of comparable properties. If similar properties have sold for less than your agreed price, the valuation may reflect that evidence.
A buyer may place additional value on a particular floor plan, location or feature that is not fully supported by recent comparable sales.
2. Property Condition
The property's condition can affect its valuation. Outstanding repairs, structural concerns, unapproved improvements or unusual property characteristics may influence the assessment. A lender may also have separate security requirements beyond the valuation figure itself.
3. Market Conditions
Property markets change. If prices have moved since comparable properties sold, or buyer demand has weakened, the valuation may differ from the amount negotiated.
4. Limited Comparable Properties
Unique homes, rural properties and properties in thinly traded markets can be difficult to compare. Different valuers may weigh available evidence differently.
5. Off-the-Plan Purchase Timing
An off-the-plan contract may be signed years before settlement. The completed property is generally assessed against conditions relevant when finance is being arranged. If the market has changed, the valuation may not support the original contract price.
Does a Low Valuation Mean You've Overpaid?
Not necessarily.
The agreed purchase price reflects what a particular buyer is prepared to pay and what a seller is prepared to accept. A bank valuation reflects an assessment made for lending purposes.
A difference between the two does not automatically prove that either figure is wrong. However, I would not dismiss a low valuation simply because the buyer likes the property. It is worth reviewing the comparable sales and understanding whether there is a reasonable explanation for the difference.
The decision about whether the property represents good value is ultimately separate from the question of whether the lender will finance it.
Can You Challenge the Bank's Valuation?
Potentially, depending on the lender and valuation arrangements. Some lenders have a formal process for requesting a valuation review or reconsideration. But a request generally needs a reason supported by evidence.
What Evidence May Help?
- An incorrect property description, land area or number of bedrooms.
- Material property features that were overlooked.
- Relevant recent comparable sales not considered in the assessment.
- Factual errors relating to the property's condition or improvements.
Simply stating that the buyer paid more than the valuation is unlikely to resolve the issue. A valuation review may confirm the original figure, result in an adjustment or identify additional concerns. There is no guarantee of an increase.
Before requesting a review, I would want to identify the actual reason for the disagreement and whether there is credible supporting evidence.
That helps determine whether a review is worth pursuing within the available timeframe.
Can Another Lender Give You a Higher Valuation?
It is possible. Different lenders may use different valuation arrangements, providers and assessment methods. However, another lender does not automatically mean another independent valuation.
Some lenders may use the same provider or accept an existing valuation. Even if another valuation comes in higher, the alternative lender must still accept the property and approve the loan under its credit policy. That includes assessing your income, expenses, existing commitments and overall serviceability.
Why I Wouldn't Submit Multiple Applications Immediately
A new lender application may create an additional credit enquiry and require another full assessment. It can also introduce time pressure when settlement is approaching. Before proceeding, I would review whether the proposed lender is realistically likely to offer a better overall outcome. For more information about how lender assessments work, read our guide on how much you can actually borrow .
What If You've Already Exchanged Contracts?
This is where the situation can become urgent. Once contracts have been exchanged, your legal obligations depend on the contract and the applicable state or territory law.
A low valuation does not automatically allow you to cancel the purchase. It also does not necessarily mean your deposit will be returned. The outcome may depend on whether the contract contains a finance condition, whether a cooling-off period applies and whether any relevant deadlines have passed.
If Settlement Is Approaching
I would prioritise three things.
- 1. Confirm the exact funding shortfall. Understand how much additional cash or lending is required.
- 2. Review available lending options. Determine whether the current lender can proceed and whether an alternative is realistic.
- 3. Contact your conveyancer or solicitor. Obtain advice about contractual rights, deadlines and whether an extension or other arrangement may be possible.
Do not assume a finance problem allows you to withdraw from a signed property contract.
Speak with your conveyancer or solicitor immediately. They can explain your legal position and any potential consequences of failing to complete settlement.
How Does a Low Valuation Affect LVR and LMI?
Your loan-to-value ratio, or LVR, compares the loan amount with the value accepted by the lender. For example, a $640,000 loan against an $800,000 property represents an 80% LVR. But if the lender accepts a value of $750,000, the same $640,000 loan represents approximately 85.3% LVR.
The Same Loan, Different LVR
| Scenario | Calculated LVR |
|---|---|
| $640,000 loan / $800,000 value | 80.0% |
| $640,000 loan / $750,000 value | 85.3% |
That difference may change the loan product available, the applicable pricing, lenders mortgage insurance or the lender's maximum permitted loan amount.
Some borrowers may qualify for an LMI waiver under specific lender policies. But an LMI waiver does not automatically remove maximum LVR or security requirements.
For a more detailed explanation, read our guide to lenders mortgage insurance and when it may be avoided .
What If You're Buying With a 5% Deposit?
A low valuation can be particularly challenging for buyers who have limited additional savings. That includes some first home buyers purchasing with a small deposit.
Even when a government scheme assists an eligible buyer with a low-deposit purchase, the lender still needs to assess the property and loan under the applicable requirements. A government guarantee should not be assumed to cover any difference between the contract price and bank valuation.
If you're a first home buyer, our guide to first home buyer government schemes, grants and concessions explains the available types of assistance. Eligibility and valuation requirements should be confirmed with the participating lender and scheme administrator.
Off-the-Plan and Construction Valuations
Off-the-Plan Purchases
Off-the-plan purchases can involve a considerable gap between signing the contract and settlement. A buyer may agree to purchase an apartment or townhouse based on market conditions at the contract date.
When the property is completed, the lender may require a current valuation. If that valuation is below the contract price, the buyer may need additional funds. This can be particularly difficult if the buyer has already paid a substantial deposit and cannot easily change the transaction.
Construction Loans
Construction finance may involve assessment of the land, building contract and proposed completed property. The lender's accepted value may not equal the total amount the borrower expects to spend.
If the accepted completed value is lower than expected, the lender may require additional equity or a revised funding arrangement. The relevant valuation method and loan conditions depend on the lender and construction proposal.
What Are Your Options When the Valuation Comes In Low?
There isn't one solution that works for every borrower. The appropriate response depends on your contract, available funds, lender policy and settlement timeframe.
Option 1: Contribute Additional Savings
If you have sufficient genuine savings, you may be able to cover the shortfall without changing lenders. But I would also consider whether doing so leaves you with adequate funds for purchase costs, moving expenses and emergencies. Using every available dollar to complete the purchase can create financial pressure after settlement.
Option 2: Review the Current Loan Structure
The lender may have other lending options, depending on its policy.
For example, the application may be reassessed at a different LVR, subject to eligibility, LMI and serviceability.
This is not guaranteed and may change the overall cost of the loan.
Option 3: Consider Another Lender
Another lender may assess the security differently.
However, we would need to review the valuation arrangements, credit policy, loan costs and settlement timing before proceeding.
A higher valuation is not guaranteed.
Option 4: Renegotiate the Purchase Price
You may be able to ask the seller to reconsider the price. Whether the seller agrees depends on the circumstances. If contracts have already been exchanged, any change should be handled through the relevant legal representatives.
Option 5: Review Additional Security
In some circumstances, a lender may consider additional acceptable security, subject to its policy and the circumstances of everyone involved. This may introduce significant risks for another property owner or guarantor.
It should not be treated as a simple way to overcome a valuation problem. Independent legal advice may be necessary, particularly where family members are providing security.
Option 6: Reconsider the Purchase
Sometimes the numbers may no longer work. If the valuation creates a shortfall that cannot be funded comfortably, it is important to understand the financial and legal implications before making another commitment. Your conveyancer or solicitor should advise on the contract, including any rights or obligations that may apply.
How Can You Reduce Valuation Risk Before Buying?
You cannot guarantee what a lender's valuation will be. But you can reduce the likelihood of being caught unprepared.
Review Comparable Sales
Look at recent sales of similar properties, not just advertised asking prices. Pay attention to property condition, land size, location and differences between the homes.
Understand Your Deposit Position
Know how much cash you have available after allowing for purchase costs. A buyer with a small deposit may have less flexibility if the lender accepts a lower value.
Understand Preapproval Limitations
A home loan preapproval does not necessarily mean the lender has accepted the property you intend to purchase. The final approval may depend on a satisfactory valuation and other conditions. You can also read our guide to what happens after you submit a home loan application .
Discuss Contract Conditions Before Signing
Your conveyancer or solicitor can explain finance conditions, cooling-off rights and settlement obligations relevant to the contract. This is particularly important at auctions, where contractual protections may be different.
Avoid Relying on One Exact Valuation Figure
If your purchase depends on the lender valuing the property at precisely the contract price, understand the consequences if that does not happen. A sensible funding plan considers what happens when the assumptions change.
How We Approach a Low Valuation at Triple O Finance
When a client tells me their bank valuation has come in low, I want to understand the whole transaction before recommending the next lending step.
That means reviewing the accepted valuation, the proposed loan, the lender's policy, the available savings and the settlement timeframe.
From there, we can identify whether there is a realistic path forward through the existing lender or whether another lending option deserves consideration.
We can assist with:
- Calculating the actual funding shortfall.
- Reviewing LVR and LMI implications.
- Checking available lender valuation review processes.
- Comparing alternative lender credit policies.
- Reviewing repayment and serviceability requirements.
- Explaining lending conditions and finance timelines.
- Coordinating finance-related matters with your conveyancer, where authorised.
We cannot guarantee that a valuation will increase, that another lender will approve the property or that settlement can be completed.
But understanding the numbers and available options early can help you make a more informed decision.
Dealing With a Low Bank Valuation?
If the bank has valued your property below the purchase price, we can review the funding shortfall, your lending options and the requirements for proceeding.
If you've exchanged contracts, also contact your conveyancer or solicitor promptly.
Get a Free Assessment