Australian couple comparing investment property options while renting an apartment, considering the costs and benefits of rentvesting.

The Real Cost of Rentvesting: Is It Worth It?

Buy where you can afford. Rent where you want to live. It sounds like the best of both worlds, but what are you giving up? Let's look at the costs, benefits and long-term trade-offs.

Rentvesting sounds like a clever compromise. You buy an investment property somewhere you can afford, while continuing to rent in the suburb where you actually want to live.

You get a foothold in the property market without giving up your lifestyle. But there's another side to the strategy that doesn't receive nearly as much attention. 

You may miss out on first home buyer assistance, take on ongoing landlord expenses, expose yourself to capital gains tax and make it harder to qualify for the home you eventually want to buy. None of that automatically makes rentvesting a bad idea. It means the decision deserves more than a comparison of property prices.

In my experience as a mortgage broker, the biggest problem is not that borrowers consider rentvesting.

It's that they sometimes compare the benefits of investing with the cost of doing nothing, rather than comparing rentvesting with the other realistic options available to them.

The important distinction

Rentvesting can help you own property sooner. But owning property sooner does not necessarily mean you will be financially better off, or closer to buying your own home later.

The Question You Should Ask Before Rentvesting

Will buying an investment property now put me in a better position to buy the home I actually want later, after all costs, taxes and borrowing commitments are considered?

This is where I would start the conversation. The question isn't simply whether you can afford an investment property. It's whether that purchase supports your longer-term objectives.

Consider two hypothetical first home buyers living in Sydney.

Buyer 1: Wants to Stay in Sydney Long Term

The first buyer works in Sydney, has stable employment and wants to buy a home to live in within the next three years. They currently have enough savings to purchase a less expensive investment property interstate.

Rentvesting may allow them to enter the market immediately.

But I would want to know whether the investment loan will reduce their borrowing capacity for their future Sydney home. I would also want them to investigate which first home buyer benefits they might lose or retain, and how much the investment property could cost to hold.

If buying the investment makes their future home purchase harder, the strategy may be working against their original goal.

Buyer 2: Expects to Relocate for Work

The second buyer works in emergency services and may be transferred between locations over the next few years. They are not certain where they want to settle permanently.

Buying an owner-occupied home in their current location could create its own problems. They might need to sell sooner than expected, pay selling costs or manage the property remotely after relocating.

For this buyer, renting near work while owning an investment property elsewhere may provide useful flexibility. The same strategy has different implications because the borrowers have different objectives.

My approach

Before comparing properties, I would first establish what you want your housing position to look like in three, five and ten years.

Then we can assess how each borrowing option affects that plan.

What Is Rentvesting and How Does It Work?

Rentvesting is the strategy of purchasing a residential property as an investment while continuing to rent the home you personally occupy.

For example, you might rent an apartment near your workplace in Sydney while purchasing an investment property in a more affordable regional market.

You receive rental income from your investment property. At the same time, you continue paying rent to your own landlord. You also remain responsible for the investment property's mortgage, maintenance, rates, insurance and other ownership costs.

The attraction is straightforward: you can potentially buy a property without having to live in the area where that property is located. But it creates two separate housing commitments that need to be assessed together.

Why Do People Choose Rentvesting?

1. Entering the Property Market Sooner

Property prices vary significantly between Australian markets. A deposit that is insufficient for an owner-occupied home in your preferred suburb may be enough for an investment property elsewhere.

This can allow some buyers to purchase earlier than they otherwise could. Whether that earlier entry produces a better outcome depends on future property performance and ownership costs.

2. Keeping Your Preferred Lifestyle

You may want to live close to work, family, schools or public transport. Rentvesting allows you to separate where you live from where you invest. For some households, that flexibility has genuine value.

3. Flexibility for Mobile Professionals

Police officers, nurses, doctors, paramedics, firefighters and Defence personnel may have changing work locations. If you expect to move, renting can provide flexibility without requiring you to sell your investment property. However, that flexibility should be compared with the costs of owning and managing property elsewhere.

4. Potential Rental Income and Capital Growth

An investment property can generate rental income and may increase in value over time. But rental income is not profit, and capital growth is not guaranteed. Property values can stagnate or decline, sometimes for extended periods.

The financial outcome depends on what happens after purchase, not simply on getting into the market.

The First Home Buyer Benefits You Could Miss

This is one of the most important parts of the rentvesting decision. When you buy an investment property, you may not qualify for assistance designed for eligible first home buyers purchasing a home to occupy.

But the rules are not identical across all schemes. It would be incorrect to assume that every investment property purchase permanently removes every future first-home benefit.

First Home Owner Grants

State and territory first home owner grants generally include eligibility requirements relating to the property and occupancy. Buying a property purely as an investment will generally not satisfy a requirement to occupy it as your home. The property type, value thresholds, residency period and prior ownership rules vary by jurisdiction.

Stamp Duty Concessions

Transfer duty, commonly called stamp duty, can be a substantial upfront purchase cost. Eligible first home buyers may receive an exemption or concession, depending on the state, property value and other conditions.

An investment purchase may not qualify for the same relief. In some circumstances, the value of a concession can materially change the comparison between rentvesting and buying a home to live in.

Government Low-Deposit Schemes

Some government-assisted home purchase schemes are designed for eligible owner-occupiers. They should not be assumed to apply to an investment property purchase. If you are a first home buyer, I recommend reviewing the available assistance before committing to a rentvesting strategy.

Our guide to first home buyer government grants, deposit schemes and concessions provides an overview of the different options.

Check eligibility before signing

First home buyer rules can depend on previous property ownership, occupancy, purchase timing, location and the particular scheme.

Confirm your position with the relevant state revenue office and scheme administrator. Do not rely on a general assumption that buying an investment property will either preserve or permanently remove every benefit.

The Capital Gains Tax Difference

The tax treatment of an investment property can be materially different from that of your main residence. Under the applicable rules, a property that qualifies as your main residence may be eligible for a capital gains tax exemption.

An investment property generally does not receive the same full main-residence treatment. That matters because rentvesting is often promoted on the assumption that property values will increase over time.

If the investment property appreciates substantially, the eventual tax consequences can become an important part of the outcome.

An Illustrative Capital Gain

Imagine an investment property purchased for $650,000 and sold years later for $950,000. The difference between those prices is $300,000. But that is not necessarily the taxable capital gain.

The actual calculation may take into account acquisition and disposal costs, eligible capital expenditure, ownership history, tax rules and available concessions. The amount of tax payable depends on the owner's circumstances and the law applicable to the transaction.

The important point is that the potential tax cost should be included in the comparison, rather than ignored because the sale may be years away.

What About Negative Gearing?

Another common argument is that a loss-making investment property can provide tax benefits. Negative gearing broadly describes a situation where deductible property expenses exceed assessable rental income.

However, a tax deduction does not make an actual cash-flow loss disappear. The applicable tax treatment also depends on current law, the nature of the property and the taxpayer's circumstances.

Any legislative changes or transitional arrangements must be considered using current official guidance. I would not make a rentvesting decision based on an assumed tax refund. Your registered tax agent should model the position using the law applicable to your circumstances.

For official information, refer to the Australian Taxation Office .

Why this matters

A property that appears attractive before tax may produce a different outcome after holding costs, selling costs and tax are included.

Tax treatment should be independently verified and should not be the sole reason for purchasing.

The Costs of Being a Landlord While You Rent

Rentvesting means becoming a landlord while remaining a tenant yourself. That creates costs on both sides.

Investment Property Expenses

  • Mortgage repayments and interest.
  • Property management fees.
  • Council and water rates.
  • Landlord and building insurance.
  • Repairs and ongoing maintenance.
  • Strata levies where applicable.
  • Land tax where applicable.
  • Vacancy and tenant-related costs.
  • Major capital works and unexpected repairs.

You also need to allow for the possibility of a period without rental income. A property that earns $650 per week in rent does not necessarily produce $650 per week available for mortgage repayments.

Your Own Rent Continues

Unlike an owner-occupier, you continue paying rent for the home you live in. That rent may increase over time. You may also face moving costs or changes to your tenancy that are outside your control. Rentvesting therefore involves both landlord risk and tenant risk.

What Does Rentvesting Actually Cost Each Month?

Let's look at a hypothetical Australian couple considering a $650,000 investment property.

Assume they contribute a 20% deposit and borrow the remaining 80%.

Illustrative Purchase

Item Amount
Purchase price $650,000
20% deposit $130,000
Investment loan $520,000
Assumed interest rate 6.50% p.a.
Loan type 30-year principal and interest
Weekly rental income $650
Rent paid on their own home $750 per week

Hypothetical figures only. The rate is an assumption, not a current lender quote. Deposit excludes transfer duty, legal fees and other purchase costs.

Illustrative Annual Cash Flow

Item Annual Amount
Gross investment rent +$33,800
Investment loan repayments -$39,441
Property management, assumed -$2,366
Rates and insurance, assumed -$3,500
Maintenance allowance, assumed -$2,000
Investment cash-flow shortfall -$13,507
Rent on their own home -$39,000
Combined annual housing cash outflow -$52,507

On these assumptions, the couple is contributing approximately $1,126 per month towards the investment property after receiving rent. They are also paying $3,250 per month in rent for their own home.

Their combined housing cash outflow is therefore approximately $4,376 per month. This is not the same as an economic loss of that amount. Part of the investment mortgage repayment reduces principal and builds equity. But it is cash that must be available each month. That distinction matters when assessing affordability.

Calculations are rounded. The example assumes 52 weeks of rent with no vacancy and a 7% management allowance. It excludes purchase costs, land tax, strata, leasing fees, tax effects, major repairs, rent increases and changes in interest rates. Actual outcomes may differ materially.

What Happens if the Property Is Vacant?

A six-week vacancy at $650 per week would reduce gross rental income by $3,900, before allowing for any additional letting costs. Your mortgage and personal rent commitments continue. This is why cash reserves matter just as much as the expected rental yield.

Rentvesting vs Buying Your Own Home vs Waiting

I would compare at least three realistic pathways, not simply rentvesting against doing nothing.

Consideration Rentvest Now Buy a Home Now Wait and Save
Property ownership Immediate investment ownership. Immediate home ownership. No immediate purchase.
Where you live Continue renting in preferred area. Live in the purchased property. Continue renting.
First-home assistance May be unavailable or affected. May be available if eligible. May preserve eligibility, subject to future rules.
Rental income Potential investment rent. Generally none from your own home. None from property ownership.
Ongoing rent expense Yes. Generally no, for the purchased home. Yes.
Property risks Investment market and landlord risks. Owner-occupier property risks. Exposure to future price movements while waiting.
Potential CGT treatment Investment property rules. Main-residence rules may apply. No property gain or loss while not owning.
Future borrowing Existing investment debt may affect capacity. Existing home debt may affect capacity. Depends on future income, savings and debts.

Notice that there is no universally superior column. Each pathway creates different opportunities, costs and risks.

The Missing Fourth Consideration: Opportunity Cost

Your deposit is also capital that could otherwise remain in savings or be used for another purpose. When you purchase an investment, you commit that capital to the property. Accessing it later may require selling or borrowing against available equity.

Both options can involve costs and restrictions. A meaningful comparison should account for the alternative use of the deposit and purchase costs.

Could Rentvesting Reduce Your Future Borrowing Capacity?

This is where our lending experience becomes particularly relevant. Suppose you buy an investment property today and want to purchase your own home three years later.

The lender will generally assess the existing investment mortgage alongside the proposed new home loan. The investment property's rental income may help, but lenders commonly apply a discount to rent when assessing serviceability.

They also consider your existing debts, expenses, income and other commitments.

Equity Is Not Borrowing Capacity

Imagine your investment property increases in value from $650,000 to $750,000. You may have additional equity on paper. But that does not automatically mean a lender will approve a larger loan. The lender still needs to assess your capacity to repay the total debt.

In other words:

Having equity does not mean you can necessarily borrow against it.

Available equity depends on the property valuation, existing debt, loan-to-value limits and lender policy. Accessing it also requires satisfactory serviceability.

What if Your Income Changes?

A promotion, career change, parental leave or reduced working hours may affect your future borrowing position. For emergency services professionals, overtime, allowances and shift penalties can also be assessed differently between lenders.

The lender that is suitable for an investment purchase today may not be the best option for your next home purchase. This is why I would assess the potential next purchase before arranging the first one, where possible.

The Risks That Become Clear Over Ten Years

Rentvesting is often evaluated using a short-term snapshot. But property ownership is usually a long-term commitment.

Property Growth May Differ Between Markets

The investment property and the suburb where you want to live may grow at different rates. Your investment might perform strongly. But if your preferred home market grows faster, the gap between what you own and what you want may widen.

The opposite can also happen. Neither outcome should be assumed.

Transaction Costs Compound

Buying an investment property creates acquisition costs. Selling it later may involve agent fees, marketing, legal costs and potential tax consequences. If you then buy your own home, you may incur another set of purchase costs. Those transaction costs can materially affect the overall return.

Cash Flow Can Change

Interest rates, rent, maintenance expenses, insurance premiums and landlord obligations may change over time. Your personal rent can change too. A strategy that is manageable today may become less comfortable if several expenses rise together.

Concentration Risk

An investment property can represent a substantial proportion of your financial position. That exposes you to a particular property, location and tenant market. Buying in an unfamiliar market can add another layer of uncertainty. If a property marketer or developer is recommending the purchase, understand their commercial interest in the transaction. Independent due diligence remains important.

What About Buying a Home First and Renting It Out Later?

There is another pathway that deserves consideration. Instead of purchasing an investment property immediately, some buyers consider purchasing an eligible home to live in, then converting it to an investment property later if their circumstances change. This may create different outcomes for first home buyer assistance and tax.

But the details matter. Any grant or duty concession may have genuine occupancy requirements that must be satisfied. The tax treatment of a property that changes from a main residence to an investment also depends on its ownership and use history.

For example, the ATO's main-residence absence rules may be relevant in certain circumstances, but they do not automatically apply to every property.

Do not structure a purchase around assumptions

If you intend to occupy a property initially and rent it out later, confirm the grant, duty and occupancy rules before buying.

Your accountant should also explain the potential capital gains tax consequences.

The purpose of comparing this pathway is not to recommend it. It is to make sure you understand that rentvesting is not the only alternative to waiting.

When Might Rentvesting Make Sense?

There are circumstances where rentvesting can be worth exploring.

When Your Preferred Location Is Beyond Your Budget

If buying where you want to live is unlikely to be achievable for an extended period, rentvesting may offer a different route to property ownership. However, you should still compare it with saving, buying elsewhere to occupy and other available options.

When You Expect to Relocate

People who anticipate frequent transfers or changing work locations may value the flexibility of renting. This can be relevant to emergency services and Defence personnel.

When You Have Strong Cash Reserves

An investment property can require unexpected expenditure. Having reserves may make it easier to manage vacancies, repairs and other disruptions.

When the Full Comparison Supports Your Objectives

The strategy becomes more meaningful when you have compared the costs, risks, borrowing consequences and tax position against realistic alternatives. The key is that the numbers should support the objective, not the other way around.

Five Rentvesting Mistakes Worth Avoiding

1. Looking Only at the Purchase Price

A cheaper property is not necessarily a better investment. Consider rental demand, holding costs, property condition and market risk.

2. Assuming Rent Covers the Mortgage

Gross rental income is not net cash flow. Management fees, repairs, vacancies and other expenses matter.

3. Ignoring First Home Buyer Eligibility

Some concessions can be financially significant. Understand what is available before purchasing an investment.

4. Assuming Equity Will Fund the Next Home

Equity may help with a future deposit. But the lender still needs to approve the additional borrowing.

5. Relying on Someone Selling You the Property

Property marketers, developers and other transaction participants may have a financial interest in the sale. That does not automatically make their information wrong. It does mean independent assessment is important.

Seven Questions to Ask Before Rentvesting

  1. 1. What is my actual long-term housing goal? Do I want to own the home I live in, and if so, when?
  2. 2. What assistance might I qualify for? Check first home buyer grants, duty concessions and deposit schemes.
  3. 3. What will the investment cost to hold? Allow for realistic expenses, vacancies and repairs.
  4. 4. Can I afford the property if rent stops? Consider cash reserves and other financial commitments.
  5. 5. How will this affect my next mortgage? Assess the existing investment loan alongside a future purchase.
  6. 6. What are the tax consequences? Ask your registered tax agent to model the relevant outcomes.
  7. 7. What happens if my assumptions are wrong? Consider lower growth, higher rates, reduced income and a longer holding period.

How Triple O Finance Can Help You Assess Rentvesting

When someone asks me whether rentvesting is worth it, I would not begin by recommending an investment property or a particular suburb. I would begin by understanding their financial objectives and what they want to achieve from borrowing.

At Triple O Finance, we can help you compare the lending implications of different pathways.

  • How much you may be able to borrow for an investment property versus a home to live in.
  • How lenders assess rental income and existing debts.
  • Potential differences between investment and owner-occupied loan products.
  • Deposit, LVR and lenders mortgage insurance considerations.
  • Estimated repayments and cash-flow commitments.
  • How the first property may affect borrowing for your next purchase.
  • Loan features and structuring considerations within the scope of credit assistance.

Your accountant should assess the tax consequences, and the relevant revenue office should confirm government concession eligibility. We cannot tell you which property will grow fastest, whether rentvesting is the right investment strategy for you, or what your future tax liability will be.

What we can do is help you understand the lending side before you make a commitment.

Considering Rentvesting?

Before buying an investment property while continuing to rent, understand what the purchase means for your borrowing capacity today and for your future home.

We can help you compare the available credit options and lender assessment requirements.

Get a Free Assessment
Nishant Ramavat, Founder, Director and Senior Finance Specialist at Triple O Finance.

Written by Nishant Ramavat

Founder, Director & Senior Finance Specialist
Triple O Finance

Nishant is the Founder and Director of Triple O Finance and a former NSW Police Officer. He helps Australian borrowers understand home loan structures, investment lending policies, refinancing and future borrowing capacity, with particular experience assisting emergency services professionals and other working Australians.

Important disclaimer: This article provides general educational information about rentvesting and residential property lending in Australia. It does not constitute personal financial, property investment, taxation or legal advice. Triple O Finance provides credit assistance within the scope of its authorisation. The suitability and availability of credit products depend on your circumstances, lender policies and credit assessment. Government grants, transfer duty concessions, tax deductions and capital gains tax treatment depend on current legislation and individual eligibility. Confirm these matters with the relevant government authority and a qualified registered tax agent. Property values and rental income may increase or decrease. Future performance is not guaranteed. All numerical examples are hypothetical and do not represent a recommendation or a prediction of investment returns. This content must be reviewed for accuracy, current legislation and licensee compliance before publication.

Nishant Ramavat, Founder, Director and Senior Mortgage and Finance Broker

Written by

Nishant Ramavat

Founder, Director & Senior Mortgage and Finance Broker

Before moving into finance, Nishant spent 14 years with the NSW Police Force. He co-founded Oz Credit and Finance Pty Ltd in 2018 with a focus on helping emergency professionals make more informed lending decisions. His experience in mortgage lending, together with further study including a Master of Financial Planning, has shaped an approach that looks beyond simply obtaining loan approval to consider loan structure, borrowing capacity and longer-term financial objectives.

Published:

Last reviewed:

First Home Buyers
Free — No Obligation

Get Your Free Assessment in Under 2 Minutes

Tell us a little about your situation. A specialist will be in touch within one business day — no pressure, no jargon.

100% Free & Confidential

No cost, no credit checks, no pressure. Just expert advice tailored to your situation.

Response Within 1 Business Day

A real specialist will review your enquiry and reach out personally.

Specialists in Your Profession

We work exclusively with Emergency Services and Essential Workers across Australia.

35+ Lenders, One Application

We compare across our full panel to find the right lender for your income structure.

Prefer to Call?

1800 000 346

Mon–Fri, 9am–5pm AEST

Request a Free Specialist Call Back

Fill in the form below and we'll be in touch within one business day.

* At least one of mobile or email is required.

Your information is secure and will never be shared with third parties.

Book an Appointment